Martin & Jones, PLLC
Call today for a Free consultation.

$6.4 Million Settlement Reached in Wrongful Incarceration Case

The City of New York has agreed to pay $6.4 million to a man who spent 23 years in prison for a murder he did not commit. David Ranta was convicted of the 1990 killing in Brooklyn of a Hasidic rabbi who had stepped into his car at dawn just as a jewelry robbery was taking place across the street. The rabbi was shot in the head and his station wagon was used as a getaway car. The Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office fought appeals and rejected evidence pointing to another killer for years. However, The District Attorney’s Conviction Integrity Unit conducted a year-long investigation after an eyewitness came forward decades after the crime to say that a detective had told him to pick the man with “the big nose” out of a lineup. David Ranta was the only person who fit that description. When investigators approached two other witnesses in the case, they immediately admitted that they had lied. Those two career criminals who implicated Ranta in the crime sought leniency from the prosecution with respect to their own criminal issues.

David Ranta has consistently maintained that a detective manufactured his confession. The detective, Louis Scarcella, claimed Ranta confessed while handcuffed to a bench at Central Booking. Although the allegation about the false confession was never proven, there had been mounting questions about Scarcella’s methods over the years which have cast considerable doubt on the alleged confession.

Prosecutors also learned that Scarcella had followed up on an anonymous telephone call attributing the killing to a robber named Joseph Astin. Scarcella questioned Astin’s wife and tried to track down a parole officer to collect recent photographs of him. Scarcella dropped that lead when Astin died in a car accident and never submitted paperwork documenting those investigative efforts. Years later, Astin’s widow came forward to say her husband was the real killer.

David Ranta is expected to also make a separate wrongful conviction claim against the State of New York. News of the settlement with the City of New York came as the current Brooklyn District Attorney convened a new three-member panel to review dozens of Scarcella’s cases. Following Mr. Ranta’s release from prison, an investigation by the New York Times found that Scarcella had used the same witness in several different murder cases and that at least six supposed confessions had included similar phraseology: “You got it right. I was there.” Some confessions did not match the evidence in the case.

David Ranta’s claim against the City of New York was settled without him having to file a lawsuit. Typically, those who have been wrongfully incarcerated must litigate their claims in court. Civil rights lawsuits, including those seeking damages for wrongful incarceration, often take years to work their way through the court and can be difficult and expensive to pursue.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information


Contact US Get Help Now

Send us an email or call us today at 800-662-1234 to speak with an attorney about your claim or to arrange a free consultation. It costs nothing to call and there is no obligation. In fact, we are not paid until your case is resolved. Se habla español. If you are unable to travel to one of our offices in Raleigh, Durham and Wilmington, we will meet with you at your location.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Raleigh Office
410 Glenwood Avenue
Suite 200
Raleigh, NC 27603

Toll Free: 800-662-1234
Phone: 919-821-0005
Raleigh Law Office Map

Wilmington Office
1213 Culbreth Drive
Suite 121
Wilmington, NC 28405

Toll Free: 800-662-1234
Phone: 910-256-4005
Wilmington Law Office Map

Durham Office
302 East Pettigrew Street
Suite 330
Durham, NC 27701

Toll Free: 800-662-1234
Phone: 919-544-3000
Durham Law Office Map