Skip to Content

Get Your FREE Consultation

Blog

Preparing the Evidence You Need in a Workers’ Compensation Case

Workers’ compensation programs originated over 100 years ago as a protection for workers hurt on the job. It was supposed to make it easy for them to receive medical care and supplementary income to support their families when a workplace injury prevented them from working. Instead of having to engage in a long, difficult lawsuit to prove that the employer’s negligence caused the worker’s injuries, the workers’ compensation program would enable workers to receive benefits without the need to prove negligence. In exchange, workers lost the right to seek compensation for their pain, suffering, and other losses. By giving up these rights, workers were supposed to gain the security of knowing they would receive help if they were hurt on the job.

Fast forward to today. The simple system intended to provide relief to injured employees is now nearly as complicated as a traditional personal injury lawsuit. Workers’ comp insurers routinely deny claims, forcing injured workers to go through multiple appeals fighting for a chance to receive the benefits that should have been theirs all along.

What does it take to succeed with a claim for workers’ compensation benefits? Evidence is critical. Acquiring the right evidence and presenting it persuasively can put you a step ahead in the claims process. Even if the insurance company denies your claim, you will have put that evidence on record for use during the appeals process. While the evidence needed will be different for each injured worker, here are some considerations to keep in mind when gathering documentation for your workers’ comp claim or appeal.

First Things First

The first two steps in the claims process don’t require evidence, but they produce evidence that you will need to keep. You need to seek medical treatment for your injury or illness. If it’s not an emergency situation and you have the ability to see a doctor chosen by your employer, then make an appointment with that doctor and make sure you get a copy of the records from that visit, including any test results. If you need immediate treatment and you go to the hospital or another facility, the same rule applies—get copies of every record you can. These records will document your condition immediately after the accident or the time you suspected that your illness was caused by a work-related factor.

Your second step after receiving medical treatment is to notify your employer of the injury. If you’re too injured to make the report yourself, someone else may do it for you. Even if you notify someone verbally, it is essential to submit a written report as well, and to keep a copy of it, along with information about how that report was delivered. The written notice should include:

  • The date of the accident
  • The date you are reporting the accident
  • A brief summary of the accident
  • A brief description of your injuries

This written notice must be provided to the employer no later than 30 days after the injury or after the time the doctor informed you of your work-related illness. Make sure you keep at least one copy of everything. Ideally, you should keep one printed copy in a file or binder in a safe place and keep an electronic copy of the same records stored on a secure cloud storage for easy access. 

These records provide evidence that you fulfilled the legal requirements for filing a workers’ compensation claim in North Carolina. In addition, they provide basic information about your injuries and the cause of those injuries. However, you will need more medical records than just those from your initial exam.

There is still one more step to meet the requirements for a workers’ compensation claim in North Carolina, but you have longer to take this step. You must complete and file Form 18 with the North Carolina Industrial Commission within two years of the injury or the diagnosis of occupational illness. You should also keep a copy of this completed form with your other initial paperwork.

Evidence to Support Your Initial Claim

Most of the time, when claims are denied, it is due to a lack of sufficient medical evidence. You need medical records, including statements from physicians, to show:

  • How the work accident caused your injuries
  • The extent of your injuries
  • How your injuries prevent you from performing your job properly
  • What your prognosis is

You may think that the records you have establish these facts clearly, but the insurance company may disagree. It is important to ensure that the evidence spells out the connections and conclusions in no uncertain terms. If there were witnesses to the accident, make note of who they are and what they witnessed. It may be helpful to take statements from them. 

Evidence to Support an Appeal

When an insurance company denies workers’ comp benefits or terminates benefits paid to a worker who had previously qualified for workers’ compensation, they are supposed to provide a reason for their action. They may claim that you’ve failed to document an essential issue when, in fact, you have documented it, just not in the language that they want to see. This is one reason it can be helpful to work with an attorney familiar with workers’ comp claims—we know what insurance companies need to check off their list to approve a claim.

It is a good idea to get additional medical records from follow-up visits and to see a different doctor if necessary. You need to show that you have been following the doctor’s instructions, which include returning for visits as recommended and refraining from certain activities.

If you have been receiving benefits, you will need medical records that show that your condition continues to prevent you from working or that you can only return to work with lighter duties or a reduced work week. If your condition gets worse, and you require additional treatment or suffer a reduction in working ability, you also need to submit medical evidence to show this.

Additional Medical Records

Insurance companies love to deny claims on the grounds that an injury or illness existed before your accident or workplace exposure. Therefore, it will be necessary to gather and submit medical records from before your injury so that these can be used for comparison.

In addition, at some point, doctors treating you for your workplace injury will determine that you have reached your level of maximum medical improvement. At that point, a determination is made about whether you should be returning to work and whether there is any permanent disability that could qualify you for additional disability benefits.

It is quite common to disagree with the doctor’s findings, so if you do, it is important to see an exam from another physician and be prepared to present those records.

Martin & Jones Helps Workers Obtain and Present Their Best Evidence to Support a Workers’ Compensation Claim

The workers’ compensation system, which was designed to provide simple assistance for workers, has turned into a complicated nightmare full of medical and legal requirements that can be tough to manage. Allow the team at Martin & Jones to help.

We understand workers’ compensation requirements in North Carolina because we’ve been helping workers get full benefits for decades. If you need to file a claim or you’re having difficulties with the claims process, call us at 800-662-1234 or contact us online now to schedule a free consultation and learn about the ways we may be able to help.

TALK TO US NOW
FOR FREE
No Win, No Fee

Review Us

Martin & Jones, PLLC logo

“Forest, once again, my family and I thank you for obtaining another settlement on behalf of my Father. It’s almost uncanny that these checks seem to come at very opportune times. This one comes as we are expecting our fourth grandchild. It will provide her some sound footing towards her future college education, plus help Mom and Dad with the medical expenses. Sometimes, I think my Dad is helping you guys with this. Maybe so. Anyway, thank you again for your hard work.”

Best Lawyers 2027 Badge
Martindale AV Badge

Contact Our North Carolina Personal Injury Law Firm

for a Consultation for Your Accident or Medical Malpractice Claim

Call us at 800-662-1234
TALK TO US NOW
FOR FREE
No Win, No Fee

The law firm you choose makes a difference. If you are the victim of an accident or an illness that someone else caused, the North Carolina personal injury law firm of Martin & Jones has the depth of experience, skills and sensitivity to make your road to recovery as smooth as possible. Whether you have experience with the legal system or have never hired a medical malpractice or personal injury lawyer before, our attorneys and staff will do our best to answer your questions, provide clear advice and prepare you and your family for what to expect. If you would like more information or to meet with one of our attorneys, please fill out the form below or call us at 800.662.1234.