What is Certification in a Medical Malpractice Case?
Doctors, nurses, and other medical professionals make mistakes all the time, just like the rest of us. Sometimes, these mistakes are made because a professional failed to provide proper care and attention, and when that’s the case, a patient who suffers from that irresponsible behavior can sue for compensation. Unfortunately for victims of medical malpractice, these cases can be quite challenging for a number of reasons.
One of those reasons is the “Rule 9(j)” certification requirement. If your doctor failed to diagnose a condition, prescribed the wrong medication, or made an error in surgery, and you want to seek compensation for the harm you’ve suffered as a result, you have to comply with certification requirements, or the court will refuse to hear your case. Since this is one of the early hurdles you face in a malpractice lawsuit, it is important to understand the certification requirement from the outset.
Understanding Medical Malpractice
Most people realize that they can’t file a lawsuit every time they get bad news at the doctor’s office. The only time it is appropriate to take a medical professional to court for their conduct is when they acted in a way that was legally negligent—either by doing something they should not have done, such as leaving surgical instruments inside a patient, or by failing to do something they should have done, such as ordering routine tests for a patient with clear symptoms of a deadly disease such as cancer.
To succeed in demonstrating malpractice, you have to show that a doctor or other healthcare provider failed to provide a reasonable level of care under the circumstances. Many factors will be considered in determining what the standard of care should have been in the situation you were in. A doctor making a diagnosis in a busy emergency room, for instance, is not expected to provide the same level of detailed analysis as a specialist you made an appointment to see regarding a specific condition. It is often necessary to call on a medical expert to prove to the court what the standard of care should have been and how the doctor’s conduct failed to meet that standard. You also need to demonstrate the harm you suffered as a direct result of the doctor’s irresponsible performance.
Before you can start making a case to show all this to the court, however, you need to fulfill basic procedural rules. This includes filing the appropriate legal documents to start your case. Rule 9(j) of the North Carolina Rules of Civil Procedure adds extra requirements for medical malpractice cases.
Certification According to Rule 9(j)
Rule 9(j) specifies that a case alleging malpractice will be dismissed by the court unless the person filing the complaint notes in the complaint that a qualified medical expert has reviewed the case and the medical records and is willing to testify that the care provided did not meet the applicable standard of care. In other words, a medical professional must certify that you have a legitimate case and won’t be wasting everyone’s time. Why is this required only in medical malpractice cases? It could be because there is a natural tendency to want to blame someone when something goes wrong, and doctors were getting blamed too often when they’d done nothing wrong. Or it could be that insurance companies or medical professionals lobbied for this requirement.
Because of the certification requirement, before you can even file a lawsuit, you need to investigate to obtain all the evidence you can get, review that evidence with your medical expert, and they must agree that it constitutes malpractice. This makes it crucial to begin working on a malpractice case with an experienced attorney as soon as possible because it takes time to obtain evidence.
Since you are likely to need evidence from an expert to win a malpractice case anyway, the Rule 9(j) certification requirement is not exactly an unnecessary step. However, it does require you to move quickly with the investigation and preparation of your case.
The “Res Ipsa Loquitur” Exception
There is one exception to the requirement that you have a medical expert certify your claim. Certification by an expert is not required if the facts of the case establish negligence under the “common-law doctrine of res ipsa loquitur.” The Latin words “res ipsa loquitur” translate to “the thing speaks for itself.” So, if the facts of the case make it obvious that someone was negligent, then it is not necessary to have expert certification at the time you file the complaint.
It is extremely rare for medical malpractice to be that obvious, however. Courts have said it only applies when an average juror with no specialized knowledge can tell just from common knowledge and experience that negligence occurred. The classic example is a surgeon leaving a scalpel inside a patient. However, having a piece of a medical screwdriver break off and get left in a surgical screw was not considered obvious negligence, and neither was a situation where a patient had cuts made in the wrong knee during arthroscopic surgery.
Rather than relying on this doctrine, it is far better to gather evidence, consult an expert, and get the certification needed to satisfy the requirement before filing the complaint.
Watch the Deadline
When preparing the records to submit to an expert for certification, it is important to be mindful of the deadline for filing a malpractice lawsuit. This deadline is known as the statute of limitations. If you file a case after the deadline has passed, the court will dismiss it, regardless of how strong your case is. That makes it vitally important to work ahead and keep the deadline always in mind.
For most medical malpractice cases, the statute of limitations is three years from the time of the negligent act. However, that time period can be extended somewhat in certain cases. If the malpractice was not easy to detect and not discovered until later, then a patient may have a year after discovering the negligent act to file a claim—but no more than four years must have passed from the time of the negligent care. If a foreign object (like a scalpel) was left in the patient’s body, the lawsuit must be filed within one year of the discovery of the object and within ten years of the time the mistake occurred.
Who is Qualified to Serve as an Expert Witness for Certification?
Rule 9(j) specifies that the person who certifies that malpractice occurred must be expected to qualify as an expert witness under Rule 702 of the North Carolina Rules of Evidence. This rule lists a number of requirements, starting with the fact that the expert must be licensed as a healthcare provider in either North Carolina or another state.
In addition, if the expert is a specialist, the expert’s specialty must be the same as that of the doctor who is being sued or be similar enough to include the procedure that is the subject of the lawsuit. During the year leading up to the lawsuit, the expert must have spent the majority of their professional time either practicing a similar area of medicine or instructing medical students in that area of medicine.
Work with a Legal Team That Understands How to Succeed in Medical Malpractice Cases
While the process of getting a qualified medical expert to approve your claim before you file adds difficulty to a lawsuit, when you plan to allow time for certification, it can help focus your case. At Martin & Jones, we have decades of experience helping victims of medical malpractice (or their families, in the case of a wrongful death lawsuit) obtain full and fair compensation for the suffering they have endured, and we know the most effective steps to take to succeed in a malpractice case.
If you or a loved one were injured because someone did not do their job properly, we invite you to schedule a free consultation to discuss the possibility of a medical malpractice claim. To schedule your free consultation, just call 800-662-1234 or contact us online now.
Share This
Contact Our North Carolina Personal Injury Law Firm
for a Consultation for Your Accident or Medical Malpractice Claim
FOR FREE No Win, No Fee
The law firm you choose makes a difference. If you are the victim of an accident or an illness that someone else caused, the North Carolina personal injury law firm of Martin & Jones has the depth of experience, skills and sensitivity to make your road to recovery as smooth as possible. Whether you have experience with the legal system or have never hired a medical malpractice or personal injury lawyer before, our attorneys and staff will do our best to answer your questions, provide clear advice and prepare you and your family for what to expect. If you would like more information or to meet with one of our attorneys, please fill out the form below or call us at 800.662.1234.